Consumer Reports Best Mattress Reviews 2023

Buying a new mattress can be a daunting task, so it’s important to use sources you trust to make sure you’re getting the right product for you. Reading Consumer Reports mattress reviews is a great way to gather unbiased information before you make a decision. For this reason, we recommend checking out Consumer Reports best mattresses for 2019 and 2023.

In this article, we’ll explain how to pick the best mattress for your sleep style, and body type in our Consumer Reports mattress buying guide. We’ll also share our top 10 best mattresses 2019 & 2023, according to Consumer Reports, to give you plenty of shopping inspiration.

Consumer Reports is an American non-profit organization that helps consumers choose the best products for their budget. It specializes in unbiased testing and reviewing and uses only the most accurate and up-to-date information. This means that you can always rely on Consumer Reports to give a fair and balanced view that can help you make the right purchase.

Consumer Reports reviews a wide range of different product types, including mattresses. It assesses all different kinds of beds, from cheap all-foam models to the most expensive luxury hybrids. Whether you’re looking for the Consumer Reports best online mattress or want to buy instore, it’s always worth checking out the Consumer reports range of mattress reviews before parting with any cash.

Best Mattress in 2023 by Consumer Reports Reviews

Now that you understand more about Consumer Reports mattress ratings and how to choose the best bed for your needs, it’s time to start shopping for your new mattress. In this website, we’ve also reviewed the top 10 products according to Consumer Reports mattress ratings. This list includes a wide range of materials and constructions at a range of firmness settings and price points, so there should be something to suit everyone.

1.Saatva Mattress

The Saatva mattress is a hybrid model highly rated in terms of Consumer Reports. Unlike many other options on our list, it comes in three firmness settings from soft to firm. It has an innerspring core, offering a high level of back support and a familiar, bouncy feel, while the pillow top finish provides excellent pressure relief.

The Saatva mattress comes in two thickness options: 11.5 inches and 14.5 inches. You won’t notice a difference between the profiles when it comes to feeling, but only the thinner version works with adjustable bed frames. However, you may be better off with the thicker version if you have a high body weight or need a more elevated bed for mobility reasons.

This mattress offers exceptional value for money and is significantly cheaper than many hybrid beds with similar premium features. Although it isn’t exactly a budget mattress, it contains advanced sleep technologies that you usually only find in a costly bed. If the full cost is too much for you to pay at once, you can take advantage of Saatva’s monthly financing arrangements.

Key Features

Innerspring core: The Saatva mattress has triple-tempered steel springs in its support unit at the base of the bed. These springs are exceptionally strong and durable, offering a much longer lifespan than many comparable models. So, the Saatva mattress is an excellent option for people with higher body weights. The springs also provide outstanding lumbar support to help combat lower back and joint pain.

Comfort Coils: Unlike many similar affordable hybrid models, the Saatva mattress comes with an extra mini-coil layer above the main support spring layer. This layer makes the bed even more supportive and lets it adapt more closely to your body’s shape, allowing more pressure relief and padding for your joints. It also helps isolate motion to prevent movements from transferring from one side of the bed to the other, letting you sleep undisturbed even if your partner tosses and turns.

Spinal Zone Technology: This mattress has two lumbar support panels that provide extra firmness around the bed’s central region and encourage a healthy sleeping position. This feature helps to reduce bad back and can, therefore, significantly improve the quality of your sleep. So, the Saatva is one of Consumer Reports best-rated beds for people suffering from night-time bad back and discomfort.

Enhanced Edge Support: The Saatva’s edges are wrapped in dense polyfoam to prolong its lifespan and stop it from sagging or becoming misshapen. This increases the bed’s usable area and means that you can lie on the edge without any roll-off effect. You can also sit on the edge without breaking down the materials underneath.

Euro Pillow Top: The Saatva mattress comes with a luxurious pillow top finish featuring contouring, plush memory foam for outstanding comfort and pressure relief. This can help to prevent joint pain. It has a breathable structure and a cotton top cover to keep you cool and comfortable at night. This cover contains the biological Guardin treatment that kills bacteria and other microbes to keep your mattress hygienic.

• Outstanding back support
• Relieves joint pressure and pain
• Three firmness options
• Two thickness settings, including a high-profile option
• Thinner version is adjustable bed friendly
• Enhanced edge support
• Good motion isolation
• 120-night sleep trial
• Free white glove delivery
• Certi-Pur certified
• Made in the USA

• Heavy and difficult to move

2.Layla Mattress

The Layla mattress is one of Consumer Reports best beds and is an excellent option if you want a memory foam bed with different firmness options. This mattress has an unusual double-sided design that lets you change the feel by merely turning it over. It has a soft side (4) that’s perfect for lightweight side sleepers and a firm side (7) that feels supremely comfortable if you sleep on your back or front.

Although the Layla mattress offers superb comfort and an impressive range of advanced features, it’s one of the most affordable memory foam beds on the market. You can often get it for a discounted price if you don’t mind waiting until a sales period to buy it. Monthly financing deals are also available if you can’t afford to buy your mattress outright.

Key Features

Dense Support Layer: Unlike most memory foam mattresses, the Layla’s support core is the central layer. This allows for its dual-sided structure. It features dense polyurethane foam that provides outstanding spinal support and encourages a good sleeping posture. It also improves the bed’s durability and stability and stops motion passing from one side of the bed to the other. So, this makes it an excellent choice for couples where one or both of you are restless sleepers.

Max Airflow Foam Layer: The Layla mattress features a Max Airflow layer on the soft side only. This layer measures 2 inches thick and gives a plush, adaptable sensation when you lie on it. This provides the deep hugging sensation that you would associate with memory foam. It has integrated air channels that let air travel through freely, stopping you from overheating while you sleep. This layer also has firmer zones where you need them for additional lumbar support.

Copper-Infused Comfort Layer: Each side of the Layla mattress has a comfort layer made from copper and gel-infused memory foam. It’s one in thick on the firm side and 3 inches on the soft side, offering a soft sleeping surface and good body contouring. It stops pressure from building up in problem areas like the hips and shoulders. The copper and gel infusions can conduct heat away so that you don’t get too hot and sticky at night. The copper particles also have antimicrobial abilities that keep your bed fresh and odor-free.

Breathable Cover: The cover is soft to the touch and can stretch and flex to accommodate your body’s movements, offering maximum pressure relief. It has built-in Thermo-Gel phase change technology that works with your body temperature to keep you cool and comfortable. Unlike many similar covers, you can remove and machine wash it to keep it hygienic.

• Comfortable in any position
• Soft and firm options
• Dual-sided structure
• Temperature neutral
• Anti-bacterial copper particles
• Cover can be unzipped and washed
• 120-night sleep trial
• Decent motion isolation
• Free shipping
• Lifetime warranty
• Made in the USA

• Not as responsive as some alternatives
• Poor edge support

3.Avocado Green Mattress

In Consumer Reports latex mattress reviews, the Avocado Green mattress scored very highly. Not only does it provide excellent back support and pressure relief, but it’s also one of the best eco-friendly options available. The company uses sustainable methods to make mattresses that don’t negatively impact the planet without scrimping on features or comfort.

This mattress features latex foam, providing the adaptability that you might associate with memory foam alongside a bouncier feel thanks to its supportive innerspring unit. There’s also a plant-based model that’s suitable for vegans.

Key Features

Zoned Support Core: The Avocado Green mattress has a supportive core unit made from 1,414 tempered steel coils. It features five distinct support zones that offer firmer support in the lumbar region to reduce back problems with extra softness and give where you need it. This unit performs very well when it comes to limiting motion transfer, so you shouldn’t feel your partner’s movements when you sleep on this bed.

Organic Comfort Layers: The Avocado Green mattress features organic materials in its comfort layers for a healthier sleep. The latex foam is sustainable and carries the prestigious GOLS certification. It offers a good balance of support and pressure relief and sleeps cooler than the more commonly-used memory foam. Above the latex layer are layers of breathable, natural GOTS certified wool and cotton that provide a soft, comfortable sleeping surface.

Optional Pillow Top: You can choose to customize the Avocado Green mattress with an optional pillow-top finish featuring an additional comfortable, pressure-relieving latex layer. This finish incurs an additional fee but could help side sleepers or those with painful joint conditions requiring extra pressure relief.

• GOLS-certified latex
• Zoned back support
• Helpful for back and joint pain
• Excellent pressure relief
• Decent edge support
• Reduced motion transfer
• No harmful fire-retardant chemicals
• Environmentally friendly
• GREENGUARD Gold certified
• Carbon neutral
• Made in the USA
• Generous 25-year warranty
• 365-night sleep trial
• Vegan version available

• No firmness options

4.Winkbed Mattress

The Winkbed mattress is highly supportive thanks to its sturdy innerspring core, but it also offers the pressure relief of memory foam in its comfort layers. For this reason, it’s rated as one of the Consumer Reports best hybrid mattress options. One of the unique selling points of the Winkbed mattress is its individual support zones. These zones promote a healthier sleeping posture and offer additional support around d the lower back. This makes the Winkbed mattress one of the best options if you want the pressure relief of memory foam but suffer from back or joint pain.

Out of all the mattresses on our list of Consumer Reports mattresses, the Winkbed offers one of the most significant ranges of firmness options. It comes in four settings from soft to very firm, so almost everyone should find a version that feels comfortable for them and meets their sleep needs. Thanks to its thick profile of 13.5 inches, this mattress is also well worth considering if you have a high body weight or need a higher profile bed for mobility reasons.

The Winkbed mattress is relatively expensive compared to some of the other top-rated mattresses reviewed in Consumer Reports. On the other hand, it still provides decent value for money when you consider its high-quality materials and advanced features. If the price tag is too high for you to buy in one lump sum, the company offers monthly payment options to make it affordable.

Key Features

Enhanced Edge Support: The Winkbeds features extra edge support around the entire perimeter. This stops the mattress from sagging or becoming lumpy, so you can expect your bed to have an extended lifespan. This additional edge support also increases the surface area available for you to sleep on and lets you sit on the side without breaking down the materials and causing damage.

Coil Support Core: The Winkbed mattress features a support core made from pocketed steel springs. This gives the bed a bouncier feel and provides outstanding back support. It has firmness zones that offer extra back support and more softness and pressure relief where you need it. This means that the Winkbed mattress is ideal for people with painful back and joint conditions. Above the base unit comes a layer of microcoils that cushion your joints and make the bed more comfortable. Although the mattress relies on coils for support, it doesn’t transfer motion like many other innerspring beds.

Euro Pillow Top: The Winkbed mattress has a comfortable Euro pillow top finish featuring two soft, adaptable memory foam layers. This provides exceptional pressure relief but won’t overheat thanks to a cooling gel infusion. Combined with the innerspring core, this pillow top finish allows the mattress to sleep exceptionally cool.

Cooling Cover: The cover features a breathable Tencel fabric that is significantly more breathable than most similar models. It has a soft, cozy feel and can draw moisture away from your body for a more comfortable sleep. It’s also extremely flexible, bending with your movements to allow you to enjoy the pressure-relieving qualities of this mattress to the fullest.

• Separate support zones
• Outstanding pressure relief
• Temperature neutral
• Limited motion transfer
• Additional lower back support
• Wide range of firmness options
• Made in the USA
• Free delivery and returns
• 120-night sleep trial
• Forever warranty
• Suitable for adjustable beds

• Relatively expensive

5.Casper Mattress

As one of Consumer Reports top-rated memory foam mattresses, the Casper is perfect for anyone looking for a combination of support and pressure relief. There’s also a budget and a hybrid option available if you’re not shopping for memory foam, giving you a few options to choose from if you like the company.

The Casper mattress is somewhat thicker than many similar beds, measuring 12 inches in total, so it’s suitable for people with high body weights who want a memory foam bed. It’s classified as medium firm, although it’s towards the softer end of this setting. So, it’s comfortable in any sleeping position but ideal for side sleepers who need more pressure relief around the hips and shoulders.

Key Features

Supportive Foam Core: This mattress has a 5.5-inch supportive base layer of dense polyfoam, providing exceptional durability and stability. This layer is relatively thick in comparison to many similar brands and offers outstanding back support. It also means that the Casper mattress provides a bit more edge support than most all-foam beds.

Zoned Support: This mattress features a 1.5-inch transitional foam layer that stops your body sinking into the dense foam beneath. It also increases the amount of support the bed can offer in various zones, so you get extra firmness around the lumbar region but more softness around your limbs and hips. This is an unusual feature for the price and makes the Casper stand out from the competition.

Open-Cell Comfort Foam: The Casper mattress has a 1.5-inch lower comfort layer featuring regular memory foam for extra pressure relief. The upper comfort layer, also measuring 1.5 inches thick, features an open-cell structure that gives the foam extra breathability for a cooler sleep. It also has a slightly bouncier, more responsive feel than you would expect from memory foam, offering decent body molding without feeling like you’re sinking into quicksand.

Washable Cover: This mattress has a cover with polyester/spandex fabric for decent breathability and a top panel of polyester. This top panel can flex with your movements to enhance the bed’s pressure relief. The cover is removable and machine-washable to help you keep your mattress clean and fresh. Replacement covers are available.

• Responsive feel
• Excellent pressure relief
• Thicker than average
• Good back support
• Removable, washable cover
• Relatively affordable and good value for money
• Zoned support
• 100-night sleep trial
• Free shipping and returns
• 10-year warranty

• Available in medium firm only
• May be a little too soft for some stomach and back sleepers

6.Nectar Mattress

The Nectar mattress has an outstanding reputation for being one of the best affordable memory foam mattresses on the market. Consumer Reports ranked it as one of their favorites. It comes in a universally comfortable medium firm feel that works for all sleeping positions, making it an ideal option for couples and combi-sleepers. That being said, it may be a touch too firm for very light side sleepers.

The Nectar mattress is exceptionally affordable compared to many of its competitors, and the range of features you get for your money is impressive. Nectar runs special offers quite often, so it’s a good idea to wait for a promotional period if you can. The company offers monthly financing options through a third party if you want to spread your new bed’s cost.

Key Features

Dense Support Foam: The Nectar mattress features a supportive bottom layer of dense polyfoam, similar to most beds of its kind. It offers outstanding back support and promotes a healthy sleeping posture to reduce discomfort in your lumbar region. It also makes the bed relatively durable and stable, prolonging its lifespan.

Adaptive Hi-Core Memory Foam Layer: This transitional layer provides a cushion between the dense core and the comfort layer and gives the bed a more responsive, bouncy feel than you might expect from memory foam. However, it still provides the same comfort and pressure-relieving benefits. So, this mattress is a good option if you like the idea of memory foam but hate feeling like you’re sinking in very deeply.

Gel Comfort Layer: This comfort layer molds closely to your body’s curves and prevents uncomfortable or painful pressure around common problem areas. It features flecks of heat-conducting gel to keep excess body heat at bay, so you’ll sleep cool in any weather. It features advanced open-cell technology to allow air to circulate, making the Nectar much more temperature neutral than most memory foam mattresses.

Quilted Foam Cover: The Nectar’s cover has a quilted finish and features plush, comfortable memory foam for a little more pressure relief, and a cozy sleeping surface. However, the Tencel-blend fabric ensures that the cover remains cool and breathable. It’s highly flexible, so you won’t lose any of the Nectar’s pressure relief when you lie on it.

• Excellent pressure relief
• Universally comfortable in any position
• Certi-Pur certified
• Adjustable bed friendly
• Temperature neutral
• Limited motion transfer
• 365-night sleep trial
• Lifetime warranty
• Free shipping and returns

• Only available in medium firm
• Unsuitable for side sleepers with very light body weights

7.Dreamcloud Luxury Hybrid

The Dreamcloud Luxury Hybrid is one of the Consumer Reports recommended mattresses and mixes the pressure-relieving benefits of memory and latex foams with the support of steel springs. It has a medium firm feel, making it comfortable in any sleeping position.

One of the standout features of the Dreamcloud is its thick profile. At 14 inches thick, it’s significantly higher than many other beds on this list, making it very supportive. This additional thickness means that it’s supportive enough for people with higher body weights. It may also be a suitable option if you need an elevated bed for mobility purposes.

Despite its name, the Dreamcloud is relatively affordable for a luxury hybrid model. It offers you the opportunity to enjoy premium features and high-quality materials for a very reasonable price.

Key Features

Enhanced Edge Support: The Dreamcloud Luxury Hybrid features a reinforced perimeter with dense foam support. This increases the usable surface of the mattress so you can lie or sit on the edge without a rolling-off feeling or damaging the materials. It also makes the mattress highly durable, stopping it from sagging and giving it a long lifespan. This allows it to support even heavier bodyweights very well.

Sleeps cool: This mattress combines breathable latex foam comfort layers and an airy innerspring core that allows unimpeded airflow. So, hot air and excess body heat can quickly leave the bed, preventing you from overheating uncomfortably at night. So, it’s a good option for people who tend to sleep hot such as women going through the menopause.

Strong motion isolation: Unlike many mattresses with innerspring cores, the DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid offers superior motion isolation. This means that you can’t feel your partner’s movements from the other side of the bed when you lie on this mattress, offering an undisturbed night’s sleep. This makes the Dreamcloud an ideal option for couples, especially if one or both of you moves around a lot in the night.

• Enhanced edge support
• Durable and long-lasting
• Temperature neutral
• Suits all sleeping positions
• Supportive enough for high body weights
• Excellent motion isolation
• Virtually silent
• Deep pressure relief
• Affordable
• Free shipping
• 365-night sleep trial
• Forever warranty

• Narrow range of sizes
• Might be too firm for some side sleepers, especially those with low body weights
• Only one firmness setting

8.Allswell Luxe Hybrid Mattress

The Allswell Luxe Hybrid Mattress offers you the chance to enjoy advanced sleep technologies without spending a fortune. Its outstandingly affordable price makes it one of the best value hybrid mattresses available on the market. The company offers 0% APR financing options through Affirm if you prefer to pay monthly.

This mattress combines the support and bounce of pocketed springs with the pressure relief and hugging sensation of memory foam. It comes in a universally comfortable medium firm setting that feels comfortable in any position, although it may feel a little hard if you sleep on your side and have a light bodyweight. It has a 12-inch profile, making it supportive enough for heavy individuals.

Key Features

Innerspring Support Core: This mattress features a supportive base layer of wrapped innerspring coils that provides exceptional back support and durability. Its structure is breathable to allow air to circulate and prevent overheating at night. This layer has a reinforced edge, increasing the surface area you can sit and sleep on and prolonging its lifespan, preventing premature sagging or loss of support.

Polyfoam Transitional Layer: This layer is 1-inch thick and features high-density polyfoam for extra support. This helps to cushion your body against the harder spring unit below and provides additional comfort.

Copper and Gel Foam Layer: This mattress’ top layer features 2 inches of adaptable, soft memory foam that can change according to your body shape and prevent uncomfortable pressure. The foam contains copper and gel particles that carry away excess body heat to keep you at a comfortable, neutral body temperature. The copper naturally repels bacteria to keep your bed clean and smelling fresh.

Quilted Top Cover: The Allswell Luxe Hybrid has a cozy, plush top cover with a quilted finish. It features additional foam with a breathable structure for a little extra pressure relief and comfortable cushioning for your joints.

• Excellent support
• Good pressure relief
• Temperature neutral
• Anti-bacterial copper
• Comfortable in any position
• Affordable
• Free shipping
• 10-year warranty
• 100-night sleep trial

• Only available in medium firm
• Not soft enough for lighter side sleepers

9.TEMPUR-ProAdapt

Tempurpedic is the most well-known memory foam mattress manufacturer and has a formidable reputation for making luxurious, comfortable beds. This is backed by its status as one of Consumer Reports best foam mattress options in 2023. It comes in three firmness options from soft to firm, making it suitable for almost anyone in any sleeping position. It has a relatively thick profile compared to other similar models, measuring 12 inches in total. This makes it exceptionally supportive for any body type, even if you have a higher than average body weight.

The TEMPUR-ProAdapt features all-foam components, except for the medium firm version that is also available as a hybrid bed if you choose. The memory foam ProAdapt lets you sink in deeply, giving a hugging feeling, whereas the hybrid has a responsive, bouncy feel thanks to its innerspring base unit.

Like all mattresses from this premium brand, the TEMPUR ProAdapt has a high price tag, although there is no price discrepancy between the all-foam and hybrid versions. If like many people, you can’t afford the high price of a Tempur mattress in one go, there are monthly financing options available if you wish to pay in stages.

Key Features

Supportive Base Unit: This mattress has a supportive, dense polyurethane base layer unless you choose the medium hybrid version, in which case the support layer features individually wrapped springs. Either version is very supportive, isolates motion, and provides a durable, stable base. The critical difference between the units is in the feel- the foam version gives a sinking-in feeling like true memory foam, while the innerspring model feels bouncier.

Adaptable Comfort System: The comfort system has two layers. The lower layer features polyfoam with a supportive, responsive feel, and the upper layer has a lower density. This lets the comfort system conform to your body shape to stop the build-up of pressure around your joints and spine. This makes the TEMPUR-ProAdapt a superb option for anyone with joint problems.

SmartClimate Dual Cover System: The top cover features innovative phase change technology that reacts to your body heat and keeps you cool. This helps the ProAdapt to remain far more temperature neutral than many similar mattresses, including others in the TempurPedic range. The cover is removable and machine washable. It also comes with an antimicrobial agent to stop bacteria and other nasties from building up in your mattress.

• Choice of three firmness options
• All-foam or hybrid options
• Couples can choose split firmness
• Outstanding pressure relief
• Strong back support
• Suitable for adjustable bed frames
• 10-year warranty
• 90-night sleep trial
• White glove delivery included

• May be too expensive for many customers

FAQS

At Sleep Aim, our readers often ask us questions about Consumer Reports and the mattresses it recommends. To help you understand more about Consumer Reports best mattress reviews, and how they can help you, check out our FAQs below.

Q: What is the best-rated mattress by Consumer Reports?

A: There is no single ‘best’ mattress rated by Consumer Reports. Consumer Reports recommends a range of beds that offer excellent material quality, features, and value for money. Which one is best depends on your personal sleep needs.

Q: Are Consumer Reports mattress reviews unbiased?

A: Consumer Reports is a non-profit organization that carries out unbiased mattress tests and reviews. So, you can be sure that any mattress reviewed positively by Consumer Reports has been assessed fairly.

Q: Are Consumer Reports mattress reviews reliable?

A: Any information used by Consumer Reports for mattress reviews is accurate and correctly sourced from reputable organizations.

Q: Should I check Consumer Reports reviews before I buy a mattress?

A: Consumer Reports is a great place to check out any mattress you’re considering buying because its reviews are independent, unbiased, and up-to-date. Alongside Consumer Reports reviews, we recommend checking out content from other sleep experts like the ones here at Sleep Aim and reviews from real-life customers.

The Bottom Line

Hopefully, you now understand why Consumer Reports is such a useful resource for people buying a new mattress. Using the Consumer Reports best mattress 2023 reviews, you can be sure that you’re getting a high-quality product and great value for money. All the beds in this article offer outstanding features at a fair and reasonable price. Which one you ultimately pick comes down to your preferences and sleep style.