Puffy are a popular online mattress brand that produce three mattresses: the original Puffy, the Puffy Lux and the Puffy Royal. Many customers struggle to choose between the original Puffy and the Puffy Lux. Although these products have key similarities, especially as they are made by the same manufacturer, there are some important differences too.
The Puffy Lux is the more premium product of the two options and therefore comes with a higher price tag. It is made of memory foam, which differentiates it from the original Puffy which has a more neutral foam feel. The truth is that both mattresses come with excellent features and provide a good level of comfort, but which one you choose comes down to your sleep needs and taste. In this article, we will compare both mattresses in detail to help settle your Puffy vs. Puffy Lux debate.
Puffy vs. Puffy Lux Construction
Both the Puffy and the Puffy Lux use a multi-layered foam construction to provide comfort and support while you sleep. However, the layers and materials use vary somewhat. It’s important to understand how each mattress is put together and how this affects your sleep experience.
Puffy Mattress Construction
The Puffy mattress has a triple-layered construction that’s reasonably typical of affordable foam mattresses. These layers combine to make a mattress that’s 10 inches thick, which is around average. Puffy use a method called Variable Pressure Foaming (VPF) to make their mattresses, which means that the foams used are made in a closed chamber. This minimizes the chemical emissions from the manufacturing process that find their way into the atmosphere, making Puffy mattresses relatively environmentally friendly. Although the comfort layers are adaptable in a way that’s similar to memory foam, the original Puffy has more of a balanced foam feeling than the Puffy Lux, which is a true memory foam mattress. The three layers are put together as follows:
The bottom layer of the original Puffy mattress is made from 6 inches of very dense foam. This provides the support your spine needs to rest in a healthy alignment and also promotes mattress stability. This type of support layer is typical of foam beds. The only drawback is that it has less edge support than other support methods found in innerspring and hybrid mattresses.
Climate Comfort Foam
The mid-layer of the original Puffy is made from 2 inches of proprietary foam that Puffy call ‘Climate Comfort Foam’. This foam is specially designed to prevent extremes of temperature and keep you at a comfortable, neutral temperature while you sleep. It also helps to bridge the gap between the foundation and comfort layers.
Cooling Cloud Foam
The comfort layer of the original Puffy mattress is made from 2 inches of visco polyurethane foam that Puffy call ‘Cooling Cloud Foam’. This is infused with gel. The advantage of a gel-infused comfort layer is that it allows heat to transfer away from your body while you sleep, preventing uncomfortable build-up during the night. The comfort layer has the ability to adapt to the shape of your body while you sleep in a similar way to traditional memory foam, which helps to relieve pressure on sore joints and increase comfort.
Stain resistant cover
The Puffy’s three layers are contained inside a stain resistant cover, which means you can wipe or spot clean minor spills and stains easily without needing to launder the whole cover. The cover can also be unzipped and washed, which is a significant advantage over many comparable foam mattresses which usually have non-removeable covers. The Puffy’s cover is Oeko-Tex® certified. We’ll explain what this means later in the ‘certifications’ section.
Puffy Lux Construction
The Puffy Lux is 12 inches thick, 2 inches thicker than the original Puffy mattress. Although the support layer works in a similar way to that of the Puffy original, the Puffy Lux contains an extra comfort layer, adding up to four layers in total. The Puffy Lux has an adaptable memory foam feel as opposed to the neutral foam sensation of the original Puffy. The layers are constructed as follows:
The bottom layer of the Puffy Lux is made from the same high-density foam as the Puffy original, but it is 7 inches thick instead of 6. This helps to make the mattress highly supportive and gives it good stability.
Climate Comfort Foam
This layer is the same as the middle layer of the Puffy original and is 2 inches thick. This foam acts as a transitional layer and helps with temperature neutrality.
Dual Cloud Foam
This is the key area where the construction of the Puffy Lux differs from the original. This layer is made from 1.5 inches of Puffy’s Dual Cloud Foam, which is highly adaptable and can closely conform to the shape of your sleeping body. This offers a high level of pressure relief and is what gives the Puffy Lux the deep hugging sensation that you would associate with traditional memory foam.
Cooling Cloud Foam
The top layer of the Puffy Lux is made from 1.5 inches of the Cooling Cloud Foam used in the top layer of the original. This is soft and comfortable to sleep on and works together with the Dual Cloud Foam layer below to give deep pressure relief.
Stain Resistant Cover
Like the Puffy original, the Puffy Lux comes with a stain resistant, Oeko-Tex® certified cover that’s also removeable and washable.
Which Mattress is Firmer?
Mattress firmness should be one of your first considerations when it comes to making a decision on which mattress suits you best. This is because it determines the level of support and pressure relief that the mattress offers. It’s important to get this aspect right, because the incorrect firmness for your sleep needs could cause discomfort, interrupted sleep and aches and pains.
You’ll often see mattresses rated on a firmness scale of 1-10, with 1 being the very softest mattress. Most people find that a medium or medium firm mattress is right for them. This is because these mattresses give good support to your spine while still having enough ‘give’ to reduce pressure on your joints.
The original Puffy mattress is classed as a medium firm mattress. You might have heard this type of bed called a ‘Universal Comfort’ mattress. This is an apt description, because this particular firmness accommodates the vast majority of sleepers very well. Therefore, it’s a good choice for couples with differing sleep styles and positions as it offers the best of both worlds between support and pressure relief. It’s also worth noting that the original Puffy has a neutral foam feel instead of the deep hugging sensation offered by the Puffy Lux, which could be an advantage if you’re one of the many people who doesn’t like the feeling of sinking in too deeply into a memory foam bed.
The Puffy Lux is the softer of the two options and is rated a medium. This should still feel comfortable for most people, although some will prefer the firmer support of the original Puffy. It conforms more closely to the shape of your body and allows you to sink in more deeply, as you would expect from a memory foam bed.
Which is Best for my Sleeping Position?
When it comes to making the choice between the Puffy and the Puffy Lux, it may well come down to your sleeping position. This is because the position you sleep in directly impacts the type of support and firmness you need. Side sleepers generally need a softer mattress to reduce pressure on their shoulders and hips, whereas back and front sleepers usually find firmer support more comfortable. Of course, if you’re one of the many people that are combi-sleepers (switching between positions in the night), you’ll need to find a mattress that suits all positions as well as possible.
The original Puffy is reasonably suitable for all sleeping positions as it is a universal comfort mattress. This makes it the obvious choice if you happen to be a combi-sleeper. Most side sleepers should find that the Puffy has enough ‘give’ to reduce pressure on their shoulders and hips. However, some side sleepers may find the Puffy too firm, especially if they have a lighter body weight.
This is where the Puffy Lux comes into its own. Although it is generally suitable for all sleeping positions, it’s particularly good for side sleepers because it can adapt closely to the side of your body. This means that you shouldn’t experience an uncomfortable build-up of pressure around your shoulders and hips that’s typical for people who sleep on their sides, even if you are very light. On the other hand, some back and front sleepers may need firmer support than the Puffy Lux can offer, especially those with higher body weights over 250 pounds.
Which Mattress is Better for Back and Joint Pain?
If you suffer from night-time back and joint pain, this can have a significant negative impact on your sleep. However, you can help to reduce your discomfort by choosing the right mattress. In fact, getting the correct mattress for your needs is probably the most important purchase you can make for easing discomfort. Ideally, you need a mattress that provides good spinal support while reducing pressure on sore and tender joints.
Many people looking for the best mattress for back pain will find that a firmer mattress is the most comfortable. This is because it will help to support your spine in the healthiest possible alignment while you sleep. If this is the case for you, you may find that the original Puffy is better for back pain as it provides firmer support than the Puffy Lux, especially if you sleep on your back or front.
If you have joint pain, especially in your shoulders and hips if you sleep on your side, you may find that the Puffy Lux does a better job at easing your discomfort. This is because the Puffy Lux is a true memory foam bed, which offers deeper pressure relief. Side sleepers are most likely to benefit from this aspect of the Puffy Lux’s construction because it can contour closely to the side of your body.
Which Mattress Sleeps Cooler?
Both the Puffy and the Puffy Lux are designed to help keep you temperature neutral. This is an important consideration if you tend to sleep hot or have a medical condition that causes night-time overheating because this can significantly disturb your sleep. However, we would not describe either mattress as truly sleeping cool. Instead, we would describe them as more temperature neutral. At the end of the day, various external factors have an impact on how hot you sleep including your bedroom climate, and a mattress is not able to control these.
If sleeping as cool as possible is one of the most important factors for you when choosing a new mattress, the original Puffy probably sleeps a little cooler. This is because it doesn’t allow your body to sink in as deeply, which means that heat won’t be able to build up as much in the area of foam surrounding you while you sleep.
Puffy vs. Puffy Lux Price Comparison
Price is one of the areas where the original Puffy and the Puffy Lux vary the most significantly. The original Puffy is the cheapest option while the Puffy Lux is a more premium product. If you’re shopping on a tight budget, this could be one of the key deciding factors in your Puffy vs. Puffy Lux debate.
The original Puffy mattress usually retails at $1,150 for a queen size. Meanwhile, the Puffy Lux is considerably more expensive at $1,795. However, at the time of writing, Puffy are offering a discount on all their mattresses during their January promotion. So, if you’re quick, you can snap up the Puffy original for $850 and the Puffy Lux for $1,495 from the Puffy website. This promotional offer includes a free king pillow worth $395.
You may be able to get either Puffy mattress for a cheaper price if you’re prepared to shop around at other online third-party retailers. However, be aware that the policies and terms and conditions may vary from those published in this article. If you’re not in a hurry to get a new mattress, Puffy and their stockists may offer seasonal discounts during the usual sale periods. However, this can’t be guaranteed.
Puffy offer monthly financing through Klarna for the Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses. This is subject to credit and affordability checks but could be a useful option if you can afford the monthly repayments but don’t have the money available to buy the mattress in a single payment.
Trials and Warranties
Both the Puffy and the Puffy Lux come with the same sleep trial and warranty because they are made by the same company. So, there’s nothing to separate the two mattresses in this regard. It’s important to make sure that you’re comfortable with the sleep trial and warranty offered because they provide you with protection.
The sleep trial offered by Puffy is 101 nights long, which is around the industry average. This allows customers to return either the Puffy or the Puffy Lux at any time during the trial period for any reason for a quibble free refund. However, it’s generally recommended that you allow at least 30 days to get used to your new mattress as this is about the length of time it takes for you to adjust to it. If you decide to return your bed, Puffy will donate your returned mattress to a local charity to provide someone in need with a comfortable and supportive bed. This also means that you can rest assured that your returned mattress won’t be adding to landfill.
The Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses come with an extremely generous Lifetime warranty, which is the longest available in the industry. The warranty is non-transferrable, which means that it can only be used by the original purchaser and isn’t valid if the mattress changes hands. The warranty protects you in the event of damage to the mattress caused by a manufacturing fault such as a crack or split in the foam. Puffy will either repair your mattress (if possible) or replace it free of charge. You aren’t covered in the event of accidental damage to the bed (for example if you burn or stain it) or for expected wear and tear. It’s also important to be aware that you are responsible for ensuring that your mattress is supported by an appropriate frame or foundation, or the warranty will be void.
Are the Mattresses Certified?
All the foams used in the Puffy and the Puffy Lux mattresses are Certi-Pur certified. This means that they are guaranteed to emit no harmful or carcinogenic chemicals or substances that could pose a risk to human health. Additionally, this means that the mattresses don’t give off substances that could cause damage to the environment.
In addition to the Certi-Pur certification, the covers of the Puffy and Puffy Lux are Oeko-Tex® certified to Standard 100. In short, this means that they are manufactured without the use of chemicals or other substances that are hazardous to human health or the environment.
As they are shipped by the same company, the shipping information for the Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses is the same. Puffy use bed-in-a-box shipping, which means your mattress arrives rolled and compressed in a compact box. You’ll need to allow up to 72 hours for your mattress to fully expand before you can use it.
Puffy ship via FedEx, and you can expect your mattress to arrive in around 3 business days after ordering. Shipping is free of charge to the contiguous USA. Customers in Hawaii and Alaska will be charged a delivery fee. Puffy also cover the costs of returning your mattress if you’re unhappy with your purchase.
Where Can I Buy the Puffy and Puffy Lux Mattresses?
You can purchase both the original and the Puffy Lux mattresses through the Puffy company website. Puffy also sell their mattresses through other online retailers including Amazon. Double check to make sure that the policies and terms and conditions are the same if you don’t choose to purchase your mattress directly from Puffy.
You can also buy additional sleep products through the Puffy website. These include bases and frames, sheets, pillows, mattress pads and protectors and a nightstand. However, it’s worth bearing in mind that these are premium products that come at premium prices. If you’re on a budget, you will be able to find cheaper options elsewhere.
Which Mattress Should I Choose?
Now that you understand the key similarities and differences between the Puffy and the Puffy Lux mattresses, you’re in a great position to make a final decision. Both mattresses should be suitable for the vast majority of sleepers, but it’s likely that one suits your needs more closely than the other. To remove any confusion, here’s our expert opinion on which mattress you should ultimately choose.
Choose the Puffy Original If:
You prefer a neutral foam feel
Although the top layer of the Puffy mattress performs similarly to memory foam, overall the bed has a more neutral foam feel. Some people don’t like the sinking, deep hug sensation of memory foam, so it’s a good option if you want good pressure relief with a bouncier feel.
You’re a combi-sleeper
The original Puffy mattress is medium firm, which means it’s a universal comfort mattress. So, it performs very well across all sleeping positions, making it a great choice for combi-sleepers who switch between positions during the night.
You’re on a budget
The Puffy mattress is considerably cheaper than the Puffy Lux. However, it still provides a great level of comfort and support, making it a good choice if you’re shopping on a tighter budget.
Choose the Puffy Lux If:
You’re a side sleeper weighing under 130 pounds
The Puffy Lux is a great choice for any side sleeper because it can adapt closely to the shape of the side of your body. However, if you have a light body weight, it’s probably going to be more suitable for your needs than the Puffy original, as it will allow your body to sink in comfortably.
You like the feeling of memory foam
Unlike the original Puffy, the Puffy Lux is a true memory foam mattress. This means that it offers the deep hugging sensation and contouring that you’d associate with traditional memory foam, which many people find very comfortable.
You need deep pressure relief
Some people require deep pressure relief, especially those that suffer from a painful joint condition like arthritis. The Puffy Lux offers superb pressure relief thanks to the adaptability of the memory foam comfort layers.
We’re often asked questions by our readers about how the Puffy and the Puffy Lux compare to each other and about our mattress comparisons in general. Here are some of the most common.
Q: What are the key differences between the Puffy and the Puffy Lux?
A: The most important factor to understand when you’re weighing up these two mattresses is the difference in feel. The Puffy mattress has a neutral foam feel while the Puffy Lux is a memory foam mattress. The firmness also differs slightly, as the original Puffy is medium firm and the Puffy Lux is medium. Apart from these two key factors, the other major difference is that the Puffy original is significantly cheaper.
Q: As the Puffy Lux is a premium product, is it better than the original Puffy?
A: Although the Puffy Lux is a premium product and therefore more expensive, it can’t really be said that it is ‘better’ than the original Puffy. The answer to this question depends on your sleep needs, sleeping position and whether you prefer a neutral foam or memory foam feel. You can follow the guidance in this article to help you decide which option is best for you.
Q: Is your Puffy vs. Puffy Lux comparison unbiased and accurate?
A: At Sleep Aim, we spend a lot of time and effort undertaking research to make sure that the information we present is accurate and up to date. Any opinions stated are our own and are formulated using our expert knowledge of mattresses and healthy sleep. We aren’t affiliated to any mattress brands and we don’t receive payment for positive reviews. Instead, we focus on creating unbiased reviews that give honest information to our readers.
The bottom line
In this article, we’ve included all the key information you need to know when you’re trying to choose between the Puffy and the Puffy Lux. Which one is best for you depends on your needs and preferences.
Buying a mattress is a major financial outlay and plays a key role in ensuring a good night’s sleep. So, we recommend researching thoroughly and comparing a wide range of mattresses to make sure you choose the right one. The expert information from the team here at Sleep Aim can help you make a more informed choice.